Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Spirituality Quotes Contrasting: St. Augustine vs. Paul Simon

Faith is to believe what you do not see; the reward of this faith is to see what you believe.

- Saint Augustine

Still a man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest.

- Paul Simon

Are your standards for accepting your religious or spiritual beliefs the same or different from other beliefs that you hold?

16 Comments:

Blogger Pauline said...
Most of my beliefs are predicated on experience. I say most, because for example, I believe China is a country; though I've never been there I've seen photos and read stories and I accept there is truth in both.

As a child I was always asking for proof - from my parents ("HOW is that good for me?" and "HOW do you know that for sure?"); my church ("How can there be such a thing as a virgin birth?" or "How can a loving God even think about limbo?"); my friends (Why CAN'T you see the fairies?" or "What do you mean, I'm weird?"); my teachers ("What exactly is gravity?" or "Prove that I will use algebra in my later life.")

Of course, there are lots of things nobody can prove and lots more things I may never experience. I believe in life (even if I can't define it to everyone's satisfaction) because I'm immersed in it. I can believe in a 'power' of some sort because I see evidence of it - in storms, in the astonishing diversity on earth, in the seasons, in growth and death. I don't believe in an all caring entity that has my best interests at heart even though sometimes I wish I did.

I would say then yes, my standards are the same for everything I believe. It's all subjective. Either I feel there's proof that satisfies me or I am convinced by what I see and experience. Whether others see and experience the same thing is not necessarily a criteria. I'll side with Paul Simon on this one.
12:25 PM  

Blogger tuti said...
i think i'm pretty aimless these days. having beliefs is one thing, facing reality is another. sometimes to keep the peace, i forgo my beliefs. not my spiritual beliefs but more so my personal.
12:57 PM  

Blogger vishesh said...
Faith is to see yourself when there is no mirror :)
1:07 PM  

Blogger Paul said...
Pauline – “It's all subjective.” But it sounds like you apply truth-testing standards of some kind...

“Either I feel there's proof that satisfies me or I am convinced by what I see and experience.”

Tuti – So by “personal belief” maybe you mean judgment?

Vishesh – Would this be more a statement about faith or knowledge?
5:45 PM  

Anonymous Kaushik | beyond-karma.com said...
Both statements are true. St. Augustine probably meant that faith is a virtuous thing, but in my experience, it is the releasing of beliefs that brings us to Truth.

We create beliefs and we experience the world through beliefs and which in turn shape more beliefs and so on, ad nauseum.

And Paul Simon is right. As Aniis Nin said, we see the world not the way it is, but way we are.

I like Pauline's comment on beliefs.

Thanks for the thought-provoking quotations.
6:48 PM  

Blogger tuti said...
perhaps by personal beliefs, i mean choice. i forgo choice for peace around. that makes 'judgement' a good choice of word too.
10:35 PM  

Blogger Paul said...
Kaushik - Another aspect of the Augustine quote might be the idea that to believe what you don't see sheds light on experience - makes it meaningful - in some way that supports or bears out the belief in things unseen.

But one person's meaning-making may be another's selective perception or circular reasoning...

Tuti - Oh, OK... you mean, for example, keeping thoughts to oneself to keep the peace with others.
11:19 PM  

Blogger Pauline said...
yes, Paul but they're my standards...
7:49 AM  

Blogger tuti said...
keeping thoughts to oneself, talking to oneself. talking to you, that is way healthier.
mostly i am ignoring my own needs to keep the peace. i hope i don't get sick(er).

..Still a man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest.
- Paul Simon

maybe that is part of the cause of my pain. others hearing themselves and not hearing others.
9:54 AM  

Blogger Paul said...
Pauline - Logical proof and empirical evidence are standards for a great many people in most areas of their day to day lives as well as in science.

Tuti - Haven't had a chance to visit your blog yet, looking forward to seeing more of what's going on with you there when I can --
5:20 PM  

Blogger Lee said...
Without a doubt, they are the same.

Logic, reason and consequence govern my world(s).
6:37 AM  

Blogger Paul said...
Lee - Seems like people tend either to have two truth standards - one for their spiritual/religious views and another for other aspects of life - or, like you, to have one standard. If the latter, they usually seem to identify themselves as skeptics or atheists.
1:55 PM  

Blogger Lee said...
Fair call. I have difficulty seeing how people of science can be religious. It has to be some sort of parallel logic system.
2:11 AM  

Blogger Paul said...
Lee - Maybe religious scientists view science as good for understanding empirical reality as far as we're able to peer into it but see limits on our abilities in that respect, let alone to comprehend the totality of what we're doing here and what being is.

Also, the words "religious" and "spiritual" cover a wide variety of perspectives some of which have almost nothing in common. Some of these perspectives stand in contradiction with science because they try to address issues that are within science's purview - for example, creation pseudoscience's critique of evolution. But there are other religious and spiritual perspectives that coexist with science, accepting its findings.
11:27 AM  

Anonymous goldflop rakeback said...
Paul Simon is one of the most talented singer/songwriters of his generation. He sings with such emotion and you can hear his soul come through the music. He is an amazing musician that deserves more attention. I hope I can see him in concert sometime!
1:57 AM  

Blogger Paul said...
Goldflop - I've really enjoyed him too - as a solo artist too, but especially with Garfunkel - the harmonic blend between the two of them was really wonderful.
11:27 PM  

Post a Comment

Post a Comment


Religion Blogs - Blog Top Sites Blog Directory Top Blogs Spirituality Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory